Energy Crane Services Logo

All Terrain Cranes vs Mobile Cranes in Construction Projects 


January 2024

Sewing machine unloaded

Cranes are the backbone of modern construction, lifting and moving heavy materials with precision and ease. However, with various types of cranes available, each suited to specific tasks and environments, making the right choice can be a daunting task. Whether you are a seasoned construction professional or new to the industry, this article will help you make an informed decision on the most suitable crane for your construction needs. 

What are Mobile Cranes? 

Defined as self-propelled cranes mounted on trucks, they offer a blend of mobility and lifting capability that is essential for various construction scenarios. The versatility of mobile cranes lies in their ability to be driven to different locations, either on roads or across rough terrain, depending on their design. This mobility is a distinct advantage over stationary cranes, like tower cranes, which require transport and assembly on-site. 

Here are a few examples of mobile cranes: 

  • Spider Cranes:  


These cranes are known for their compact size and lightweight construction, making them perfect for projects where space is limited or for tasks within buildings. Their design allows for easy transport to higher floors or confined areas that larger cranes cannot access. Spider cranes are equipped with stabilising legs that extend outwards, resembling the legs of a spider, which provide stability during lifting operations. They are commonly used in tasks like lifting building materials within a construction site or for indoor maintenance and installations. 


  • Crawler Cranes 


Designed for heavy-duty lifting, crawler cranes are equipped with tracks instead of wheels. This track system allows them to traverse and operate on rough and uneven terrains, making them ideal for large-scale construction sites. Crawler cranes vary in size, with mini versions that can navigate public roads to larger ones that are confined to site use. Their main advantage is their significant load capacity, which makes them suitable for lifting heavy materials like steel beams or large machinery. 


  • Franna Cranes 


Also known as taxi cranes, Franna cranes are celebrated for their exceptional versatility. They can quickly pick up and transport materials over short distances within a worksite, such as moving equipment in workshops, mines, or plant sites. Their design combines the mobility of a truck with the lifting capability of a crane, allowing them to relocate materials efficiently without the need for additional transport equipment. 


What are all-terrain cranes? 

All-terrain cranes are a versatile and powerful class of mobile cranes, engineered to operate efficiently in both on-road and off-road scenarios. These cranes are a hybrid between a mobile truck crane and a rough terrain crane, combining the best of both worlds: the mobility and speed of truck cranes with the ruggedness and off-road performance of rough terrain cranes. 

Key Characteristics of All Terrain Cranes: 

  • Dual Application Design: All Terrain Cranes are built for versatility, capable of travelling at speed on public roads and navigating challenging off-road conditions with ease. This dual-nature design makes them highly adaptable to a wide range of construction environments. 


  • Flexibility in Use: The adaptability of All Terrain Cranes extends to various construction projects, from urban developments with easy road access to remote areas with rough terrain. This flexibility allows them to be a valuable asset in diverse construction scenarios, including large-scale industrial projects, infrastructure development, and commercial construction. 


Mobile Cranes vs All Terrain Cranes 

  • Performance and Versatility 

When it comes to performance, both mobile cranes and all-terrain cranes offer distinct advantages. Mobile cranes, particularly specialised types like crawler and rough terrain cranes, excel in specific conditions such as indoor spaces or rugged terrains. All Terrain Cranes, on the other hand, provide an all-in-one solution with their ability to perform in various environments without the need for specialised adaptation. 


  • Terrain Adaptability and Load Capacity 

In terms of terrain adaptability, All Terrain Cranes have an edge over standard mobile cranes due to their hybrid design. They can navigate both smooth highways and challenging off-road conditions, making them suitable for a broader range of sites. In addition, All Terrain Cranes generally have a higher load capacity compared to traditional mobile cranes, offering more substantial lifting power. 


  • Operational Efficiency and Cost Comparison 

Operational efficiency is a crucial factor in crane selection. All Terrain Cranes, with their ability to travel at highway speeds and perform in rough terrains, reduce the need for additional transportation and setup, which can lead to significant time and cost savings. 


Cost-wise, the initial investment for All Terrain Cranes is typically higher than standard mobile cranes due to their advanced features and capabilities. However, this higher upfront cost can be offset by their versatility and reduced need for multiple crane types on varied projects. Ongoing operational expenses, such as maintenance and transportation, also play a role in the total cost of ownership and should be considered when comparing these two types of cranes. 


Key Factors in Crane Selection 

When selecting the right crane for a construction project, several critical factors must be taken into account to ensure the efficiency, safety, and cost-effectiveness of the operation. Understanding these key elements can guide you in making an informed decision that aligns with your project's specific requirements. 

  • Site Conditions:  

The nature of the construction site plays a significant role in crane selection. Factors such as the terrain (whether it's uneven, muddy, or paved), space constraints, and accessibility determine whether an All Terrain Crane or a specific type of Mobile Crane is more suitable. 

  • Load Requirements: 

Assessing the weight and dimensions of the materials to be lifted is essential. Different cranes have varying lifting capacities and reach. Ensure that the crane you choose can handle the maximum load expected on the site. 


  • Project Duration:  

The length of the project also influences crane selection. For short-term projects, renting a crane might be more viable, whereas for longer-term projects, purchasing or leasing could be more cost-effective. 


  • Costs: 

The impact of the crane selection on the overall project costs is a critical consideration. This includes not only the rental or purchase costs but also transportation, setup, and operational expenses. It’s important to balance the initial investment with the operational efficiency and versatility of the crane. For example, an All Terrain Crane might have a higher upfront cost but could provide savings in transportation and setup over the project's duration. 


  • Safety: 

Safety is paramount in construction, and compliance with industry standards cannot be overlooked. The crane chosen must meet all regulatory safety requirements for the specific project and location. Consider features like stability, load management systems, and emergency safety mechanisms. Additionally, ensure that the crane operator and crew are adequately trained and certified to handle the specific type of crane being used. 


Expert Advice and Best Practices 

Choosing the right crane for a construction project is a decision that significantly affects the efficiency, safety, and cost of the project. Industry experts emphasise several best practices and tips to ensure that this decision is made wisely. 

Here are a few tips from Scope Cranes & Logistics when looking to hire a crane: 


  1. Assess the Full Scope of the Project: Before selecting a crane, thoroughly understand the project's requirements including load capacities, heights, and distances. This ensures that the crane chosen is capable of meeting all the demands of the project. 


  1. Consult with Crane Specialists: Leverage the expertise of crane specialists who can provide valuable insights based on their experience. They can help identify the most suitable crane type for your specific project needs. 


  1. Factor in Environmental Conditions: Consider the site’s environmental conditions such as wind, weather, and ground stability. These factors can significantly impact crane operation and should guide your selection process. 


Scope Cranes & Logistics' Expert Crane Hire Solutions 

As you weigh your options, remember that Scope Cranes & Logistics is here to assist you every step of the way. Our extensive range of crane hire services is designed to meet the varied demands of modern construction projects. With our expert guidance and comprehensive fleet, which includes both All Terrain and Mobile Cranes, you can be confident in making a choice that maximises efficiency, safety, and cost-effectiveness for your project. 

At Scope Cranes & Logistics, we pride ourselves on delivering top-notch crane hire services backed by a team of experienced professionals. We understand the intricacies of construction projects and are committed to providing solutions that align perfectly with your project goals. So, when it comes to your next construction endeavour, consider partnering with us for a seamless and successful experience. Contact Scope Cranes & Logistics today to explore how our crane hire services can elevate your project to new heights. 

Sewing machine loaded
Want to talk about your specialist crane requirements? 
Contact today to discuss your next project and get a free quote.
Scope Cranes & Logistics Logo



Map Marker-altFont Awesome Free 5.0.6 by @fontawesome - License - (Icons: CC BY 4.0, Fonts: SIL OFL 1.1, Code: MIT License)

3B/420 Bilsen Road
Geebung, QLD 4034

PhoneFont Awesome Free 5.0.6 by @fontawesome - License - (Icons: CC BY 4.0, Fonts: SIL OFL 1.1, Code: MIT License)

© Scope Cranes & Logistics Designed By

iSeekplant logo

Fill out the form below for a free quote. Or call (07) 3865 2705.

Energy Crane Services Logo